PSR header
Home  |  Upcoming Events  |  Newsletters  |   Contact Elected Reps  |  Donate  |  Contact IPSR  |  About IPSR
(last updated 03/08/09)
Code Black--cancelled
THE PROPOSED COAL-FIRED POWER PLANT 
  WOULD HAVE INCREASED NEEDLESS DEATHS AND HUMAN SUFFERING.
WHAT'S NEXT ?
CODE
BLACK
A Medical Emergency

Dangerous to your health
Page Index:
Learn about the PSR's national
CODE BLACK Campaign.
COAL'S 7 DEADLY THREATS
  1. Carbon Dioxide Emissions  (CO2, Global Warming)
  2. Volatile Organic Compounds (VOC)
  3. Fine Particulate Matter (PM 2.5)
  4. Mercury
  5. Sulfur Dioxide (SO2)
  6. Nitrogen Oxides (NOx)
  7. Environmental Destruction

The Latest News


Is there a legislative solution to bring back the Alliant plant?

From the Marshalltown Times Republican March 8, 2009:    http://www.timesrepublican.com/page/content.detail/id/515181.html?nav=5005



Towards Energy Independence in Iowa -- What's Next?

by Paul Deaton, Chairman Johnson County Board of Health 3/7/09:    http://www.blogforiowa.com/blog/_archives/2009/3/7/4115470.html


Alliant Cancels Marshalltown Coal-Fired Power Plant Proposal

Plans cancelled for proposed Sutherland Generating Station Unit 4 hybrid power plant

Partners appreciate broad support for project by Marshalltown community, labor partners, business leaders, political leadership

MARSHALLTOWN, Iowa – March 5, 2009 – Interstate Power and Light Company (IPL), a subsidiary of Alliant Energy Corporation (NYSE: LNT), cancelled plans to construct the proposed Sutherland Generating Station Unit 4 in Marshalltown, Iowa. The project’s other partners are Central Iowa Power Cooperative (CIPCO), Corn Belt Power Cooperative (Corn Belt) and North Iowa Municipal Electric Cooperative Association (NIMECA). 

The decision to cancel the project is based on a combination of factors including the current economic and financial climate, increasing environmental, legislative and regulatory uncertainty regarding regulation of future greenhouse gas emissions and the terms placed on the proposed power plant by regulators.

“Our company and our partners appreciate the tremendous support demonstrated for this project by our labor partners, industry, agriculture and business leaders, the community of Marshalltown and economic development organizations across the state," says Tom Aller, president-IPL. “While our company is disappointed in this missed opportunity to further Iowa’s efforts to grow its economy and position our state as a leader in renewable energy, we will continue to focus our efforts on expanding our renewable energy resources and energy efficiency initiatives and reducing our environmental impact.

Our company still has an obligation to serve customers with safe, reliable and environmentally responsible energy at a reasonable cost. We will continue developing new energy resources, such as our construction of the Whispering Willow wind farm, which is expected to be in service by 2010, as well as investing in our existing power plants to enhance their production while reducing their impact on the environment. In addition, over the next six to twelve months, our company will evaluate its energy supply options as we prepare to meet the energy needs of future generations of Iowans.”

“Today’s decision is not in the best interest of our cooperative or our state, but it is the hand we were dealt,” said Dennis Murdock, CIPCO Executive Vice President and CEO. “CIPCO was committed to the Sutherland project as a solution to providing an affordable and reliable supply of electricity with a renewable component. While the economic slowdown has dampened short-term forecasts for energy growth, we still have a need for baseload electric generation to serve our members. We will continue to pursue other opportunities to meet the growing needs of our members to foster economic growth and job creation.”

Ken Kuyper, executive vice president and general manager, Corn Belt Power Cooperative, states, “It’s regrettable that this plant won’t be built. This new source of generation was an important part of our plan for meeting the growing demand for electricity from the people of rural Iowa. Corn Belt Power will work to determine the next best alternative to the Sutherland plant. We will continue to do everything we can to meet our co-op members’ need for reliable and affordable power.”

“Our members are disappointed that the project will not be moving forward,” said Greg Fritz, NIMECA CEO. “When combined with our existing hydro, wind, and coal resources this hybrid plant would have provided the energy necessary for continued economic development and growth in our member communities. We will be exploring other opportunities to provide our members with the energy necessary for their communities to grow and prosper.”


( back to top )
The Threats
  1. Greenhouse gas emission and associted global warming and ocean acidification.
  2. Sulfer dioxide (SOX) and nitrogen oxides (NOX)
  3. Volatile organic compounds (VOC)
  4. Heavy metals emmisions:  organified mercury, arsenic, lead, cadmium
  5. Fine particulate mattter:  PM2.5
  6. Coal ash spills
( back to top )
Take Action Now


Write:

The Iowa DNR has extended the public comment period for the Draft Air Quality Contstruction Permit for the proposed Iowa Power and Light (Alliant Energy) coal-fired powerplant in Marshalltown Iowa. The proposed plant in Waterloo, IA has already been defeated through your action.

Please submit a written comment to the Iowa DNR by May 18, 2009.  All the necessary information you should need to understand the issues and to compose a comment is in this document:



Comment in Person:

Already scheduled are four public hearings (two each at two locations).  Additional hearings are planned throughout Iowa to be concluded by the tend of the extended public comment period May 18, 2009:

March 16, 2:30 p.m. – 5 p.m., Iowa Veterans’ Home, Whitehill Chapel, 1501 Summit Street Marshalltown
March 16, 6:30 p.m. – 9 p.m., Iowa Veterans’ Home, Marshalltown

March 17, 3 p.m. – 5 p.m., Meskwaki Tribal Center, 346 Meskwaki Road, Tama
March 17, 7 p.m. – 9 p.m., Meskwaki Tribal Center, Tama

Please attend and speak at one of the upcoming DNR Public Comment Hearings March 16 & 17, 2009.  If you attend and speak you will have 5 minutes to express your concerns.  You are asked to provide your comments in writing for the permanent Hearing record.


( back to top )

Progress in Iowa


On January 7, 2009 Elk Run Energy Associates (affiliate of N.J.-based LS Power) abruptly dropped the proposed 750-megawatt Elk Run Energy Station to have been built in Waterloo, Iowa. 

From the AP release:
Carrie La Seur, president of the Cedar Rapids-based environmental group Plains Justice, said she wasn't surprised the project didn't come to fruition.  "Really, with the kind of developments we've seen over the last several months in the credit markets and for coal fired plants in particular, I guess we were waiting to hear the final nail get hammered into the coffin," said La Seur, whose group has been a leader in opposing the plant. "I'd have been very surprised if they were able to build a coal plant."  She said the decision was vindication for her group's stance.  "Our position all along has been that there are far better and less risky options available to the Cedar Valley and Iowa as a whole for development," she said.


On January 14, 2009 the Iowa DNR announced it would review the Coal Ash Rulemaking Process
Due to the action of Plains Justice, Des Moines Register investigative reporting, and public concerns, the Iowa DNR plans to revisit the coal ash rulemaking process to protect Iowa water from coal ash contaminatiion.  To learn more about coal ash and recent spills review the Resources section  below.


Public Comment Period Extended for IPL’s Marshalltown facility
Urbandale, February 27, 2009 – Due to extensive interest, the public comment period for the draft air quality construction permits for the coal-fired power plant proposed by Interstate Power and Light for its Marshalltown facility—Sutherland Generating Station—has been extended to May 18. Public hearings will also be held in five additional cities.



Iowa DNR Comment Period Extended

Iowa DNR News
Environmental Services Division


For immediate release February 27, 2009

MEDIA CONTACT:
Chris Roling, Construction Permits, (515) 242-6002 or Chris.Roling@dnr.iowa.gov

Public Comment Period Extended for IPL’s Marshalltown facility

Urbandale – Due to extensive interest, the public comment period for the draft air quality construction permits for the coal-fired power plant proposed by Interstate Power and Light for its Marshalltown facility—Sutherland Generating Station—has been extended to May 18. Public hearings will also be held in five additional cities.

Currently scheduled are four public hearings (two each at two locations):
March 16, 2:30 p.m. – 5 p.m., Iowa Veterans’ Home, Whitehill Chapel, 1501 Summit Street Marshalltown
March 16, 6:30 p.m. – 9 p.m., Iowa Veterans’ Home, Marshalltown
March 17, 3 p.m. – 5 p.m., Meskwaki Tribal Center, 346 Meskwaki Road, Tama
March 17, 7 p.m. – 9 p.m., Meskwaki Tribal Center, Tama

Due to the many comments received from particular areas of the state, additional public hearings have been scheduled in Council Bluffs, Davenport, Des Moines, Iowa City and the Waterloo/Cedar Falls area. Specific times and sites have not been determined at this point, but the hearings will likely be held in early May. As soon as that information is available it will be released to the public.

The public hearings are for the purpose of accepting comments only. Comments at the public hearings will be limited to five minutes. Presentations shall include a hard copy for inclusion into public record.
Comments may also be submitted in writing before 4:30 p.m., May 18, to Chris Roling, Air Quality Bureau, Iowa Department of Natural Resources, 7900 Hickman Road Ste 1, Urbandale, IA 50322 or emailed to chris.roling@dnr.iowa.gov.

All documents for this project are available on the DNR Air Quality Bureau’s Web site at http://aq48.dnraq.state.ia.us:8080/airpermit/eecomment.jsp
# # #
Written by Mindy Kralicek

For more information from local activists about the Marshalltown and Tama Public Hearings please call:
641-752-7056 for Marshalltown or 641-484-3139 for Tama



( back to top )
Iowa Partners Fighting Coal

Community Energy Solutions
Environment Iowa
Iowa Environmental Council
Iowa Global Warming
Iowa Interfaith Power & Light
Physicians for Social Responsibility, Iowa Chapter
Plains Justice
RE-AMP Global Warming Strategic Action Fund
Sierra Club, Iowa Chapter

( back to top )
Resources


Coal-Fired Power Generation

National PSR Code Black Campaign
Physicians for Social Responsibility Fact Sheet
Coal-Fired Power Plants:  Understanding the Health Costs of a Dirty Energy Source

The Iowa Department of Natural Resources
Website on Air Quality

American Lung Association Fact Sheet
Particulate Matter

The US Environmental Protection Agency
Particulate Matter

The Sierra Club Compass Blog
Coal ash spills

Plains Justice Report
Iowa Coal Combustion Waste Disposal


Black Lung: Anatomy of a Public Health Disaster by Alan Derickson; Cornell University Press, 1998, 238 Pages

The Sustainability Revolution: Portrait of a Paradigm Shift by Andres R. Edwards; New Society Publishers, 2005, 206 Pages

Big Coal: The Dirty Secret Behind America’s Energy Future by Jeff Goodell; Houghton Mifflin Company, 2006,  324 Pages

Earth: The Sequel by Fred Krupp and Miriam Horn, W. W. Norton & Company, 2008, 278 pages


Nuclear Power

Insurmountable Risks:  The Dangers of Using Nuclear Power to Combat Global Climate Change
by Brice Smith
IEER Press and RDR Books, 2006, 448 pages, paperback
In depth analysis of all aspects of nuclear power compared to other alternatives for electricity generation. Download executive summary of book or purchase hard copy at:

Physicians for Social Responsibility Fact Sheet
Dirty, Dangerous and Expensive:  The Truth about Nuclear Power

Bad Reactors:  Rethinking your opposition to nuclear power?  Rethink again.
By Mariah Blake
Washington Monthly, January/February 2009
Economics of nuclear power featuring current nuclear plant construction fiascoes and the anatomy of subprime nuclear loans.


Renewable Energy

The Stimulus Package's Poor Energy Choices
by Michael McCalley PhD MD, former PSR Executive Directory
Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, February 2009

Carbon Free and Nuclear Free:  A Roadmap for U.S. Energy Policy
by Arjun Makhijani PhD
IEER Press and RDR Books, 2007, 257 pages, paperback
Download entire book free or purchase hard copy at
Feasibility study of going nuclear and carbon free in the U.S. by 2050.

20% Wind Energy by 2030 Report (www.20percentwind.org)

U.S. Dept. of Energy
Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy

National Renewable Energy Laboratory

American Wind Energy Association

Emerging Energy Research




( back to top )
Maps & Directions


( back to top )
Contact Us

Iowa PSR
20 East Market St, Room 200
Iowa City, IA 52322


Email:

 
( back to top )



Iowa PSR  is the Iowa statewide chapter of the national organization, Physicians for Social Responsibility (PSR).  
PSR is the United.States affiliate of 
IPPNW was recipient of the 1985 Nobel Peace Prize.

Iowa PSR is composed of a diverse group of health care workers, health science students and concerned citizens committed to preserving the health and well being of all people through research, education, and advocacy.   As part of PSR and IPPNW, Iowa PSR is especially committed to advancing nuclear disarmament and nuclear security,  prevention of gun violence, and the preservation and promotion of safe environmental policies.  These three man-made health threats have a massive global impact on public health and security and our concern for each of these issues guide our actions and organizational policies. For more information visit our About Us page.

This website is a continually growing endeavor. 
To offer suggestions or comments about the content of this website, please 
Thank you for your support!


Home  |  Upcoming Events  |  Newsletters  |   Contact Elected Reps  |  Donate  |  Contact IPSR  |  About IPSR